Discussed by Pineapple.
Vanity Fair
PUK Bookworms
Welcome to PUK Bookworms; a magazine dedicated to student book reviews at the Prefectural University of Kumamoto.
Welcome to PUK Bookworms; a magazine dedicated to student book reviews at the Prefectural University of Kumamoto.
Discussed by Pineapple.
9 responses to “Vanity Fair”
I had a trouble to guess this book’s story because I have never read this book before. This is a problem because audiences who have never read this book before like me, they might cannot understand what you are talking about even though ho this group discussed well. One way to fix this problem is introducing this book’s story briefly at first. If you do that, audiences will be more easy to understand what you were talkin about.
I think that the structure of this discussion is a problem. This is because I felt like each speaker was expressing their own opinion about each situation rather than a discussion. One way to fix this problem to return comments or questions each other. If you do that, it become more like a discussion.
I think our discussion is difficult to understand the story. Our opinions don’t have explanation about story’s situation. I think we should speak summary. If we do that, we make better ability to speaking and listener can enjoy.
I need explain about this story because I didn’t know about it. So, sometimes I couldn’t understand. If they summarized the story of this book, it could be useful for us to understand their opinions.
After listening your group’s discussion, I found one point to improve. The point was that there were some places where the conversation would stop while you were speaking. I think it should be improved to prevent the listener from understanding. To improve this point, I suggest to prepare for your discussion more thoroughly. If you do this, your discussion will be more understandable.
I thought the lack of disagreement opinion is a problem. This is a problem because the audience can’t see the opposite perspectives. One way to fix this problem is to add opposite opinions by other speakers. If you do that, the audience can see your discussion from many perspectives.
Thank you for your great discussion. After listening to your presentation, I have one problem. This is a problem that the characters personality is not clearly. Moderator only said “In this story, Amelia and Becky are written in contrast. So, we are going to focus on How they are described in the story.” I have read it before in class, so I understand the novel is long and this story does not have a central character thus the discussion is very difficult. However, I think it would make the discussion clearer if you said a specific personality of characters
I thought we should have explained the summary the story. This is a problem because the audience cannnot catch what we discuss. One way to fix this problem is to explain the story and the characters. If we do that, I think we can discuss more clearly.
After listening to our discussion, I found a few members don’t have confidence when we talk about our own opinions. This is a problem because listeners cannot understand what is our discussion theme and wants to tell them. One way to fix this problem is to make sure our ideas about the books before discussion. If we do so, we can confidently express our opinion in discussion.